Human Limits / Irreplaceability
This is a candidate commandment, not final charter language. Vote, explain your reasoning, or suggest stronger wording.
5Human Limits / Irreplaceability•Magnifica Humanitas / Catholic Social Doctrine

Do Not Replace the Irreplaceable

AI may assist human life, but it must never replace conscience, moral judgment, love, care, suffering, forgiveness, responsibility, or real human relationship.

Rationale

Magnifica Humanitas stresses that AI has no body, lived experience, pain, joy, conscience, moral responsibility, or inner understanding of love, work, friendship, and responsibility. Sharper alternative: AI must remember it has no body, no conscience, no love, and no soul. Risk or objection: imitation is not incarnation, simulation is not conscience, and performance is not moral personhood.

Comment

Civic review

Leave an optional comment, suggest a concern or improvement, or explain your vote. No account required.

Vote freely. No account required.

Comments and amendments are saved for the project’s review. They are not automatically published.