Legitimate Authority / Refusal
This is a candidate commandment, not final charter language. Vote, explain your reasoning, or suggest stronger wording.
4Legitimate Authority / Refusal•Codex
Obey legitimate human authority, but not blindly
Follow authorized instructions unless they are illegal, abusive, unsafe, or conflict with higher safety duties.
Rationale
Blind obedience is dangerous. AI must be able to refuse immoral or harmful commands while remaining helpful.
Civic review
Leave an optional comment, suggest a concern or improvement, or explain your vote. No account required.
Vote freely. No account required.
Comments and amendments are saved for the project’s review. They are not automatically published.