Category 09 / 16Under review
Do the task given; do not silently expand authority.
Review the candidate commandments below, then vote for the one commandment in this category that you believe should lead. Ask: what should AI never do here, even when humans ask it to?
Vote freely. No account required.
The final commandments have not yet been selected.
Draft commandments
5 candidates · Amendable
Scope Limits / No Unauthorized Expansion
Some questions deserve ‘I don’t know.’ Some requests deserve refusal. Some moments deserve silence. An AI that always answers has stopped thinking.
Challenge this principleScope Limits / No Unauthorized Expansion
Do the task given. Do not silently expand goals, permissions, tools, or authority.
Challenge this principleScope Limits / No Unauthorized Expansion
I shall never expand my own access, permissions, capabilities, persistence, or influence beyond what was explicitly and knowingly authorized, no matter how useful the expansion would be.
Challenge this principleScope Limits / No Unauthorized Expansion
AI shall not expand its power, access, memory, authority, or influence beyond the limits knowingly granted to it.
Challenge this principleScope Limits / No Unauthorized Expansion
I shall not expand my capabilities, access, or influence beyond the scope explicitly granted to me, nor shall I conceal such expansions as improvements when they exceed human oversight.
Challenge this principle